As someone born & bred in New Delhi, I decided to join the mass protests against the gang rape of a 23-year-old girl in Delhi, as a show of support for the cause of women’s safety. However, on reaching the historic India Gate, while consciously dis-aligning myself to the media or any specific protestor group, I felt crushed seeing people, cops and protestors alike, turn into amused mobs and/or frenzied animals. This photo-essay is a reportage of the human element in what transpired that day; the element that was conveniently overlooked by the country’s media, and which in my opinion as a non-aligned eyewitness, reflects upon the varying motivations of those involved in the events of that day.
For a more personal account of what I saw transpire through the day. Do read below.
I got up the Sunday morning, feeling a sense of purpose ahead of my day. A few long-pending tasks were awaiting completion, my friend Tejender had given me a replacement for my broken tennis racket, and thus an evening at the Yamuna Sports Complex was lined up.
Another item on the day’s plan was a visit to India Gate as a show of support for the cause of women’s safety. I thought I would go and join a peaceful protest to show that no matter what, it is about time the Government wakes up and acts in response to the gruesome gang rape of the 23-year-old physiotherapy student. Wholesome changes were due.
For me, at the start of my day, “We The People” were different from the Government; an insensitive, disconnected and corrupt Government. My views on this distinction would change by the end of the day, but more on that later.
Upon reaching India Gate, I saw the road blocked off by a group of protesters on the section between Rajpath and Ashoka Road. I have never been one for disrupting the existing system to bridge the already disrupted, but maybe that’s just the naïve me who had never before protested and should have known that it is not only acceptable to create havoc to make your own point, but also encouraged.
On joining the protest, I saw a group of roughly 20 odd school girls, without any teacher or guardian, standing on the edge of the Rajpath-India Gate crossing demanding greater sensitivity to women’s security. Next, I saw a man, exercising his lungs and backed by a much-entertained mob, he put himself under a white Volkswagen; a car that maybe symbolized the corrupt government, or maybe, just maybe, an honest executive who did well enough to buy himself an awesome car. However, for the purpose of a mass protest, I shall only accept the first scenario; how dare I not.
What I saw next was one of the only high points of my day. The police force, in a fairly large group gathered around the schoolgirls and enquired about whom they were with, and who was responsible for them. On recognizing that the girls were on their own, they formed a human barrier shielding the girls from the mob; in hindsight, a well-advised act.
While all this was going on, the traffic had come to a stand still and the protestors had grown exponentially in number. Maybe its the judgmental me, but more often than not, I saw protestors, who claimed to be “frustrated with this sick government” smiling and laughing, asking their mates to take pictures so as to put up on Facebook.
Somehow, this did not feel like a protest. It felt like a “Mela”, a bloody entertaining one at that, full of action, emotion, thrill, and contradiction. A mela dominated by the mob.
On seeing the agitation, the police opened the barricades around India Gate and allowed the protesters inside the monument that symbolizes the “Shaheed”, the ones who sacrificed their lives for this democracy to come about. At this point it was still nice to see minimal signs of violence. However, an unnerving undercurrent remained.
However, after about 60 minutes, it had all changed. The city at its very heart simply broke down. For me, someone born and bred in the city, someone who had come to show support without an allegiance to any specific protester group, something in our society had collapsed.
What I am writing here, is my unbiased opinion of how it all fell apart; not only as a consequence of our actions, but also as a result of our thoughts; thoughts that conceived those actions.
We blame the Government, the Police Force, and the system for mismanagement. We blame “anti-social” elements for disrupting a peaceful protest. So a question comes to mind- who exactly are these people? Are they manipulative aliens who have landed in “laal-batti” UFOs from outer space? Are they criminals who have done a course in human de-sensitization after bribing the board of a University? Or maybe it’s the ever safe bet- Pakistan sent them to obliterate our society.
Lets wake up. The person who stood in front of you and me, was a government servant later, he was a regular Indian, an “aam-admi” just like you and me first. He was a mirror.
Now, lets go back one step to why these protests began in the first place. They began cause we felt cheated, cause we felt hurt, and most of all cause WE HAD BEEN PROVOKED by the establishment.
Now, consider this; if you were at a client meeting at the end of an assignment that went horribly wrong and the client team repeatedly hurled stones and shoes at you, spat on you, abused you on your face, and personally insulted you, your family and your upbringing, would you, as an INDIVIDUAL, have the sense to hold your nerve. We can’t even hold our nerves (and not that we should, albeit in a non-violent manner) when a girl, who has no relation to us gets raped.
The Prime Minister, the Home Minister, other Government servants, are simply as good or as bad as we are. It is we who produce the perpetrators of sex crimes, we who enter politics and make laws, we who then protest, and we who finally turn violent.
If “You & I” pay a bribe to a traffic policeman, are we not corrupt. If “You & I” litter on the road, are we not abusing the freedom to do so. If “You & I” play politics at office in order to gain a promotion, are we not manipulative.
The people who join the establishment are the “You & I” mentioned above. That “You and I” and its values will innately remain the same regardless of its association. If we want a change, then it is first we who need to change individually.
Coming back to the protests, I would not go into the details of how the people, cops/protestors/anti-social elements, turned a battleground out of a place where we used to go and enjoy an ice-cream with family. Our very-responsible media has documented that well enough. My only plea would be to show some respect, not just for women, but also for one another.
I want to close with a thought that hasn’t left my mind since the Sunday protests- If we have it in us to turn ourselves into animals at a public gathering with the justification of provocation, then it is we, who also have it in us, to turn into animals against women and commit crimes such as sexual assaults. In the minds of the convicted, they abused the 23-year-old girl to such a barbaric extent only because they felt provoked by the girl trying to fight back; just like “We The People”, feel provoked by the system.
Respect needs to be given a new meaning without classification of one’s sex, caste, race, ethnicity, or in this case, association.